Amended Motion for Class Certification (4/9/19) (Plaintiffs)
Response to MPSJ (4/9/19) (Plaintiffs)
Motion for Summary Judgment (4/9/19) (Plaintiffs)
4/12/19: OPEN LETTER TO THE
ARIZONA LEGISLATURE, AND CC TO SUN CITY, AZ "LIAR GRAY LEADS REPUBLICANS TO RUIN THE PLANNED COMMUNITIES ACT" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula
Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject: This opinion piece exposes the lies perpetuated by Republican Rick Gray and RCSC General
Manager Jan Ek in order to get RCSC pulled out of the planned communities act. They want CLOSED MEETINGS
AND CLOSED RECORDS! They want to discredit a respected Superior Court Judge's ruling that RCSC is under
the Act since 1994. They are trying to escape facing the consequences of disobeying the Act since its inception.
DO NOT BE DUPED! VOTE NO ON SB1094!
click here to download file: Liar Gray leads Republicans
4/04/19: Anne Reports HB2374 IS NOT DEAD! SNEAKED UP AS SB1094!! Late 3/25/19 this bill number showed up on the Agenda for the House Government
Committee with hundreds of FOR votes when the bill wasn't even seen by anyone. We suspect someone signed up people without
their knowledge. By voting "FOR",
the voter is saying he wants CLOSED
MEETINGS AND CLOSED RECORDS at RCSC.
See if your name or that of anyone you know is on the list. Call us if you did not want to have your name used like this. Call Anne Stewart at 602-318-0708
or email at anne@annereport.com. If SB1094 passes, these people's
names will go down in infamy. They are personally responsible for the total loss of membership power in Sun City.
click here to download file: List of people FOR SB1094
04/03/19: Newspaper Articles "PCA bill passed in House Committee---Still faces further debate" by
Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent Newsmedia, April 3, 2019.
click here to download file: 4/3/19 Ind-SB1094 passes House
04/03/19: Newspaper Articles "PCA bill revived in Arizona Legislature---Effect of PCA bill continues to be chagrin of community" by
Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent Newsmedia, April 3, 2019
click here to download file: 4/3/19 Ind-SB1094
3/23/19: Anne Reports HB2374 IS DEAD! Thank you, Senator David Farnsworth for not allowing this bill to be heard in the Senate Government Committee,
which killed the bill. It's a win-win
for those FOR and AGAINST. Those who were FOR wanted Sun City to remain a 55+ community. Those who were AGAINST
wanted open meetings and open records. Since the planned communities act will not remove the age overlay, remaining
in it will have no negative effect in that regard. Therefore, RCSC will remain in the PCA as it has always been since
the act began in 1994. RCSC just didn't comply is all. Until our lawsuit.
03/20/19: Newspaper Articles "PCA does not jeopardize Sun City age overlay"
by Plaintiff Attorneys Ashley Hill and Jonathan
Dessaules, Sun City Independent, March 20, 2019, GUEST COMMENTARY Pages A8 and A10 Subject Continuing in RCSC's
effort to defeat the lawsuit that determined it must obey the planned communities act (open records and meetings!),
Rep. Kevin Payne (District 21) has introduced HB2374 to pull them out of the PCA. RCSC claims judge is wrong and that
they will lose age overlay. BOTH UNTRUE!! Plaintiffs' attorneys, Ashley Hill and Jonathan Dessaules counter Rep. Payne
saying age overlay threat by PCA is not true. They also say he is misinformed and using scare tactics. RCSC should follow
the ruling of the judge for open meetings and records. What's wrong with that? CALL
TO ACTION! VOTE NO ON HB2374! CONTACT SENATE REPUBLICANS PLEASE!!! ESPECIALLY DAVID FARNSWORTH, CHAIR OF
SENATE GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE at 602-926-3020 or email at DFARNSWORTH@azleg.gov. https://www.azleg.gov/MemberRoster/?body=S
click here to download file:3/20/19 Guest Commentary
03/20/19: Newspaper Articles "RCSC: RCSC board to consider Grand Project ---
PROJECT: Renovation cost pegged at $6 million"
by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent, March 20, 2019,
COMMUNITY Pages A4 and A5 Subject: Attend RCSC Board meeting at
Sundial Auditorium, 9am, Thursday, March 28, 2019, to protest this expenditure since it requires a membership vote according
to Article X of the RCSC Articles of Incorporation. This is at issue in an ongoing lawsuit. Why is the board choosing
to do this now? The hearing is set for August 2019. Also, at issue is the PIF Fund. They shouldn't be spending
it. It may have to be returned.
click here to download file: 3/20/19 Article re $6M Grand Project
03/20/19: Newspaper Articles "RCSC: RCSC officials propose bylaw, board policy
changes--Some residents ask why the rush" by Rusty
Bradshaw, Sun City Independent, March 20, 2019, Front Page continued on Pags 3 Subject: Attend RCSC Board meeting at Sundial Auditorium, 9am, Thursday, March 28, 2019, to protest the motions.
They are approving $6M without a membership vote, charging PIF to those on deed at time of death of remaining owners who didn't
pay PIF, closing corporate records according to Title 10 when they are under open records Title 33, and more. See The Anne Report notes at the end of the article. Click on the following link to see the Agenda
for 3/11/19: https://suncityaz.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Exchange-Agenda-3-11-19-with-Motions-11.pdf
click here to download file: 3/20/19 Article re Motions
03/13/19: Newspaper Articles PCA BILL: "Arguments against Title 33 nonsense" by Ex-RCSC Board Member Carol Martinez, Sun City Independent, March 13, 2019, LETTERS A8 Subject Continuing in RCSC's effort to defeat the lawsuit that determined it must obey the planned communities
act (open records and meetings!), Rep. Kevin Payne (District 21) has introduced HB2374 to pull them out of the PCA.
RCSC claims judge is wrong and that they will lose age overlay. BOTH UNTRUE!! Carol Martinez supports the PCA saying
Rep. Payne told some "whoppers" in his opinion piece that was trying to get Sun City to support his dastardly bill
HB2374. CALL TO ACTION! VOTE NO ON HB2374! CONTACT SENATE REPUBLICANS
PLEASE!!! ESPECIALLY DAVID FARNSWORTH, CHAIR OF SENATE GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE at 602-926-3020 or email at DFARNSWORTH@azleg.gov. https://www.azleg.gov/MemberRoster/?body=S
click here to download file: 3/13/19 Martinez Opinion-HB2374
03/13/19: Newspaper Articles "No danger to Sun City age overlay from PCA"
by Ex-RCSC Board Member Bill Pearson, Sun City Independent,
March 13, 2019, GUEST COMMENTARY Pages A8 Subject Continuing in RCSC's effort to defeat the lawsuit that determined it
must obey the planned communities act (open records and meetings!), Rep. Kevin Payne (District 21) has introduced HB2374
to pull them out of the PCA. RCSC claims judge is wrong and that they will lose age overlay. BOTH UNTRUE!! Bill
Pearson says age overlay threat by PCA is a not true. CALL TO ACTION! VOTE
NO ON HB2374! CONTACT SENATE REPUBLICANS PLEASE!!! ESPECIALLY DAVID FARNSWORTH, CHAIR OF SENATE GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE
at 602-926-3020 or email at DFARNSWORTH@azleg.gov. https://www.azleg.gov/MemberRoster/?body=S
click here to download file: 3/13/19 Opinion-HB2374 Bill Pearson
03/13/19: Newspaper Articles "PCA bill now in hands of Arizona Senate"
by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent, March 13, 2019,
COMMUNITY Pages 4 and 5 Subject Continuing in RCSC's effort to defeat the lawsuit that determined it must obey
the planned communities act (open records and meetings!), Rep. Kevin Payne (District 21) has introduced HB2374 to pull
them out of the PCA. RCSC claims judge is wrong and that they will
lose age overlay. BOTH UNTRUE!! CALL TO ACTION! VOTE NO ON HB2374!
CONTACT SENATE REPUBLICANS PLEASE!!! ESPECIALLY DAVID FARNSWORTH, CHAIR OF SENATE GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE at 602-926-3020
or email at DFARNSWORTH@azleg.gov. https://www.azleg.gov/MemberRoster/?body=S
click here to download file: 3/13/19 HB2374 to Senate!
3/4/19: Anne Reports STOP HB2374!!! CALL
TO ACTION! The Recreation Centers of Sun City, Inc., (RCSC) got Representative Kevin Payne (District
21) to pull them out of the planned communities act!! The bill has moved to the Senate Government Committee. We expect
dirty tricks like at the House where they changed the time so we couldn't speak. See testimony from that hearing where they
read off our names to speak but not one of us is there. Then, go to Jan Ek's testimony and the lobbyist saving her when
she couldn't answer the question why Judge Brodman is wrong when he ruled RCSC is under the PCA. Click here for the 2/7/19
Part 2 hearing video. We need you to write to the ALL
of the Senators. In subject line write: VOTE NO ON HB2374! Keep Sun City under the PCA!!! Call and email Senate
Members [ https://www.azleg.gov/MemberRoster/?body=S ] to say NO!! Ask the Republicans why they are against the Planned Communities Act with its open workshop
meetings and open records. Are they for the ending the PCA altogether? For those of you who want to upload the Senate Members onto your email server for mass
mailings, use the following txt files:
"D" means Democrats only. "R" means Republicans only Save the txt files to your computer and then upload them from your email server.
click here to download file: 2019 Senate Members - D
click here to download file: 2019 Senate Members - R
click here to download file: List of people FOR and AGAINST HB2374
NOTICE HOW MANY LAWBREAKING BOARD MEMBERS ARE LISTED FOR HB2374.
02/23/19: Newspaper Articles "PCA bill gets committee OK---Appears to be headed
for House floor fight" by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City
Independent, February 23, 2019, Front Page Top Story, continued on Pages 24 and 30 Subject The RCSC is trying to defeat the lawsuit that determined it must obey the planned communities
act (open records and meetings!). Rep. Kevin Payne (District 21) has introduced HB2374 to pull them out of the PCA.
RCSC claims judge is wrong and that they will lose age overlay. BOTH UNTRUE!! CALL
TO ACTION! VOTE NO ON HB2374! CONTACT HOUSE REPUBLICANS PLEASE!!! Especially TONY RIVERO, our representative. https://www.azleg.gov/MemberRoster/?body=H
click here to download file: 2/23/19 Ind-HB2374 House Fight
2/13/19: "RCSC---Misinformation being sent to residents" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula
Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject: This opinion piece exposes Jan Ek's
corporate email blast as misinformaiton to get support for House Bill 2374. Ek claims if the bill RCSC wrote doesn't
pass RCSC will lose the 55+ age overlay. A LIE! Truth is if it passes RCSC will not be under the Planned Communities
Act even though a Judge said they were. They do not want to comply and they want to stop our lawsuit that compels compliance.
DO NOT BE DUPED! VOTE NO ON HB2374!
PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, FEBRUARY 13, 2019, OPINION, LETTERS
TO THE EDITOR, PAGES 8 and 9.
click here to download file: 2/13/19 Opinion-HB2374 Ek Lies!
01/30/19: Newspaper Articles "LAW -- Bill to exempt rec centers from law --
Aims to overturn court order" by Rusty Bradshaw,
Sun City Independent, January 30, 2019, Front Page Top Story, continued on Pages 10 and 13 Subject The RCSC is trying to defeat the lawsuit that determined it must obey the planned
communities act. Rep. Kevin Payne (District 21) has introduced HB2374. CALL TO ACTION!
VOTE NO ON HB2374!
click here to download file: Independent 1/30/19 --- HB2374
1/24/19: Anne Reports STOP HB2374!!! CALL
TO ACTION! The Recreation Centers of Sun City, Inc., (RCSC) got Representative Kevin Payne (District
21) to pull them out of the planned communities act!! Call and email House and Senate Members to say NO!! For those of you who want to upload the Senate and House Members onto your email server for mass mailings,
use the following txt files:
click here to download file: 2019 House Members - All
click here to download file: 2019 House Members - D
click here to download file: 2019 House Members - R
click here to download file: 2019 Senate Members - All
click here to download file: 2019 Senate Members - D
click here to download file: 2019 Senate Members - R
"All" means all the members of the chamber without regard to Party. "D" means Democrats only. "R" means Republicans only Save the txt files
to your computer and then upload them from your email server.
1/20/19: Anne Reports STOP HB2374!!! CALL
TO ACTION! The Recreation Centers of Sun City, Inc., (RCSC) got
Representative Kevin Payne (District 21) to pull them out of the planned communities act!! Call and email to say NO!! Representative Kevin Payne (District 21), kpayne@azleg.gov,
(602) 926-4854 SUMMARY:
HB2374 removes RCSC from the planned communities act. Plaintiffs won in Court. The Judge found RCSC is held to
the planned communuties act. Open meetings! Open records!
Representative Kevin Payne, District 21 (Sun City, A COMPANY
TOWN!), is Prime sponsor for the bill. This bill is not good for Sun City homeowners.
The planned communities act protects homeowners from bad boards of RCSC. The RCSC boards will not be held accountable
if HB2374 is passed. It is unfair.
Our lawsuit is in discovery on many other counts, as well, and we have a court date set
during the summer.
RCSC
is trying to pull a fast one on the RCSC Members! PLEASE HELP US DEFEAT THIS OUTRAGEOUS BILL THAT TRIES TO DEFEAT OUR
LAWSUIT. VOTE NO ON HB2374!
09/19/18: Newspaper Articles "LAWSUIT -- Plaintiffs gain partial victory --
Judge orders Sun City is a planned community" by
Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent, September 19, 2018, Front Page Top Story, continued on Page 9 Subject: Oral Arguments recording and Judge's ruling can be accessed on http://www.annereport.com/developments.html. We won first part of our lawsuit. Is RCSC a planned community?
Judge ruled YES. The class action certification is delayed until the discovery and motions are completed for the rest
of the lawsuit on issues, i.e., Is the RCSC charging unequal fees? STAY TUNED. See Calendar on Case History.
click here to download file: September 19, 2018, Article
click here to download file: COURT RULING, September 4, 2018
SUMMARY: Is RCSC held under the Planned Communities Act? YES!! Is this a Class Action Lawsuit? No, but will be allowed to ask again after discovery of the remaiining counts. A WIN FOR PLAINTIFFS!
08/21/18: Class Action Developments Is the RCSC held to The Planned Communities
Act? Is this lawsuit a class action? Click
on the following link to listen to the Oral Arguments at Superior Court on August 21, 2018!
COURT RECORDINGS: (Click on the following link)
08/1/18: Newspaper Articles "Oral arguments set for RCSC lawsuit", Sun City Independent, August 1, 2018, LOCAL NEWS, Page A4 Subject: Motions made, answered, and final reply are on http://www.annereport.com/developments.html. Plaintiffs contend RCSC must follow the State's Planned Communities
Act; RCSC contends it does not. Plaintiffs contend this action to be a class action; RCSC contends it does not. Oral
arguments are on August 21, 2018. It will be a partial summary judgment. See Calendar on Case History.
click here to download file: August 1, 2018, Article
07/12/18: Newspaper Articles "Oral arguments next up for RCSC lawsuit. All
documents in judge's hands" by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun
City Independent July 11, 2018, Page 4, continued on Page 5 Subject:
Motions made, answered, and final reply are on http://www.annereport.com/developments.html. Plaintiffs contend RCSC must follow the State's Planned Communities
Act; RCSC contends it does not. Plaintiffs contend this action to be a class action; RCSC contends it does not. Oral
arguments are expected in August 2018. It will be a partial summary judgment. See Calendar on Case History.
click here to download file: July 11, 2018, Article
06/29/18: Class Action Developments We are done with the motions and responses
for this first phase. Coming up will be a COURT DATE for oral arguments! Click on the following links to read the last of the motions in this phase:
Response to Motion for Summary Judgment (5/18/18) (Defendant)
Response to Motion for Class Certification (5/18/18) (Defendant)
Reply to Response to Motion for Summary Judgment (6/22/18) (Plaintiffs)
Reply to Response to Motion for Class Certification (6/22/18) (Plaintiffs)
03/30/18: Class Action Developments All interrogatories, admissions, and depositions are finished. We
are finally addressing the issues. This phase has two: 1) Is the RCSC held to the Planned Communities Act? (We say it
is.) and 2) Is this a Class Action lawsuit? (We say it is.). Click on the following links to read our motions to the court:
Motion for Summary Judgment (3/30/18) (Plaintiffs)
Motion for Class Certification (3/30/18) (Plaintiffs)
06/21/17: Newspaper Articles "Planning for the future, RCSC board to consider reinstating
committee" by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent
June 21, 2017, Front Page Story, continued on Page 6 Subject: In
the discussion of reinstating the Long Range Planning Committee, RCSC made admissions that the board is continuing to have
meetings in secret and announcing their decisions to the members without membership input. They are blaming the class
action lawsuit for their not spending money on North GC Pro Shop.
click here to download file: 6/21/17 Independent Article
05/24/17: Newspaper Articles "PLANNING, RCSC planning committee could return,
Will participate in Grand Avenue property evolution" by
Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent May 17, 2017, Front Page Story, continued on Page 7 Subject: In the discussion of what to do about the Grand Avenue property, RCSC made admissions that
the board is continuing to violate Article X's spending limits, and the planned communities act's open meeting laws.
click here to download file: 5/17/17 Independent Article
5/24/17: UPDATE: Defendant RCSC is trying to rig pending class action lawsuit! FHA won't do mortgages in Sun City because of RCSC transfer
fees ($3,800), yet, Sun City's Senator Debbie Lesko was successful at getting
the Legislature and the Governor to approve unlimited transfer
fees on Sun City seniors. Her bill got passed and signed!!!
2/28/17: Anne Reports A group of us caravaned down
to the House of Representatives to give testimony in opposition to SB1175, transfer fees. Defendant RCSC made Senator
Debbie Lesko sponsor a bill that would "clarify" the law so that they could alter the outcome of one of our causes
of action about the $3,500-PIF in our pending class action lawsuit. The bill is retroactive to 2010! SB1175 PASSED THE SENATE UNANIMOUSLY WITHOUT DEBATE BECAUSE WE DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT IT
AND DIDN'T SHOW UP TO OPPOSE. When we found out, we started emailing and calling both the Senate and the
House to tell them about what was behind the bill. And when it was assigned to the House Commerce Committee, we all
drove down there to give testimony. We made some headway. One "NO" vote from a representative who is an attorney
who thought changing laws during a lawsuit was a problem, one "PRESENT" who might vote "NO" on the floor.
Others voted "DO PASS", though they said they might vote "NO" on the floor. So, SB1175 is being
sent to the RULES committee. We must write the RULES committee and OPPOSE SB1175. Our emailing list will get the
info. For those who want to watch the fireworks, click on
the following link: "HOUSE COMMERCE COMMITTEE VIDEO 2/28/17 2PM" Keep calling the House
of Representatives, especially the Rules committee. We will object to this bill all the way to the Governor. You eat
an elephant one bite at a time.
02/28/17: Newspaper Articles "LOANS BEING DENIED. Rec center policies create obstacle"
by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent March 1, 2017,
Front Page Story, continued on Page 7 Subject: FHA is refusing loans
because of the Preservation and Improvement Fee ("PIF"). Most concerning to seniors are the refinance and
the reverse mortgages. We must strike SB1175 at the House because
it allows RCSC to levy unlimited PIF. Our RCSC lawsuit was filed in Superior Court on October 29, 2015. It is ongoing.
Senator Debbie Lesko is on the side of RCSC against the homeowners. She got SB1175 passed out of the Senate that is
intended to interfere with our pending litigation regarding the Preservation and Improvement Fee. It will make the PIF
legal retroactively to 2010, the statute of limitations! The Senate was never told the real reason behind the bill before
they voted unanimously in favor. We have to kill this underhanded action by Senator Lesko in the House. We must call
the House of Representatives and tell them to VOTE NO ON SB1175!
click here to download file: "LOANS BEING DENIED. Rec center policies create obstacle."
2/17/17: "Bill attempts to get RCSC off the hook" by Anne Randall Stewart,
Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
This opinion piece is against Senator Debbie Lesko's bill SB1175 that is an attempt to interfere with our class-action lawsuit
against the RCSC regarding the legality of charging the Preservation and Improvement fee. The bill makes it legal RETROACTIVE
to 2010! Lesko is taking sides against the homeowners. She doesn't have enough information to justify doing that.
Call the House of Representatives (click here for contact information) and tell them to vote NO on SB1175.
Let the court decide.
DUE TO BE PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, FEBRUARY 22, 2017, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
click here to download file: "Bill attempts to get RCSC off the hook"
02/15/17: Newspaper Articles "BILL COULD CLARIFY FEE. Request for law tied to lawsuit"
by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent February 15, 2017,
Front Page Story, continued on Page 6 Subject: Our RCSC lawsuit
was filed in Superior Court on October 29, 2015. It is ongoing. This article shows that Senator Debbie Lesko is on the
side of RCSC against the homeowners. She got a bill passed out of the Senate that is intended to interfere with our
pending litigation regarding the Preservation and Improvement Fee. It will make the PIF legal retroactively to 2010,
the statute of limitations! The Senate was never told the real reason behind the bill before they voted unanimously in favor.
We have to kill this underhanded action by Lesko in the House. We must call the House of Representatives and tell them to VOTE NO ON SB1175!
click here to download file: "BILL COULD CLARIFY FEES. Request for law tied to lawsuit."
02/04/17: Newspaper Articles "RCSC halts PIF projects. Ek: Caution due to pending
litigation" by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent
February 1, 2017, Front Page Story, continued on Page 10 Subject:
Our RCSC lawsuit was filed in Superior Court on October 29, 2015. This article shows that the RCSC is finally paying
attention to the real possibility it will be held accountable for non-compliance with state statutes and the community documents.
click here to download file: "RCSC halts PIF projects"
5/27/16: Newspaper Articles "APPROVAL: RCSC
OKs parcel purchase" by Jeff Grant, DAILY NEWS-SUN, May 27, 2016, Top Front Page Story continued on Page A4 Subject: At the board meeting on Thursday, 5/26/16, the RCSC Board of Directors approved purchasing
property on Grand Ave at 103rd Avenue for $750,000 which will cost more to build to suit. This action required a Membership
vote according to Article X of the RCSC Articles of Incorporation. Our lawsuit which has been filed and is proceeding
addresses this issue as well as many others. Stay tuned...
click here to download file: "APPROVED: RCSC OKs parcel purchase"
12/16/15: Class-Action Developments The RCSC Answer to the Complaint was filed on December
11, 2015. We have a link to it on the Class-Action Developments tab. In it, there are no surprises. We are on track thanks to our supporters who made this lawsuit
possible.
Click on the following link:
RCSC Answer to Complaint (Defendant)
11/25/15: Newspaper Articles "See you in court" by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent November 25, 2015, Front Page Story, continued on Pages 2 and 7 Subject: Our RCSC class-action lawsuit was filed in Superior Court on October 29, 2015.
This article gives a summary of the Nine Counts and lets everyone know to see annereport.com for details. There
were some errors in the report which were corrected by Anne Report within the article itself in red underlined [like this].
click here to download file: "See you in court"
11/13/15: Class-Action Developments The Class Action was filed on October 29, 2015.
The "Class-Action Developments" page contains the case history link so you can follow developments. Also,
we have started the documents list with the Filing Cover Sheet and the Complaint. It's been a long time coming, but
we are now on the way. We thank our supporters who made it possible.
Click on the following link for the Superior Court Docket to follow
developments:
Click on the following links for complaint documents:
Class-Action Cover Sheet
Class-Action Complaint
6/10/15: Newspaper Articles "Long-range changes get opposition" by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent June 10, 2015, Page 2, continued on
Page 7 Subject: At the Sundial board meeting on Thursday,
5/28/15, RCSC voted to approve more million-dollar projects without a Membership vote against Article X of the RCSC Articles
of Incorporation. Also, there was finally a split between the board members where we finally have someone voting "no".
Director Dave Wieland complained that board members should not debate in public but instead at the secret work sessions
where the members are shut out. That action goes against the Planned Communities Act. We are going forward with a much-needed class action lawsuit against RCSC over many causes of action,
including these two. We have enough plaintiffs to qualify for a class action. We will file during the summer. It's not too late if you want to be a plaintiff to possibly get reimbursed for illegal
assessments. Contact Anne Stewart at 602-318-0708 or 623-933-6192. Fundraising has ceased. We are funded. It
won't cost anything to be a plaintiff.
click here to download file: "Long-range changes get opposition"
6/2/15: Newspaper Articles "RCSC's long-range capital budget
calls for sweeping renovations" by Jeff Grant, DAILY NEWS-SUN,
June 2, 2015, Top Front Page Story continued on Page A5 Subject:
At the board meeting at Sundial on Thursday, 5/28/15, RCSC approved more million-dollar projects without a Membership vote
against Article X of the RCSC Articles of Incorporation. We are going forward with a much-needed class action lawsuit
against RCSC over many causes of action, including this one. We are contacting plaintiffs who, additionally, want RCSC
to restore our membership meetings and the membership quorum, comply with the planned communities act for open meetings and
open records, and treat members equally according to Article VIII.5. The members who are being victimized are singles
paying a per lot assessment, homeowners whose primary Arizona residence is within 75 miles of Sun City, residents who are
not owners, owners with multiple properties, people who paid the PIF, and members who buy guest cards. If you want to
be a plaintiff to possibly get reimbursed for illegal assessments, contact Anne Stewart at 602-318-0708 or 623-933-6192. Fundraising
has ceased. We are funded. It won't cost anything to be a plaintiff.
click here to download file: "RCSC's long-range capital budget calls for sweeping renovations"
5/20/15: Newspaper Articles "More RCSC renovation in store" by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent May 20, 2015, Front Page Story, continued
on Page 7 Subject: At the board meeting at Sundial on Thursday,
5/28/15, RCSC will vote to approve more million-dollar projects without a Membership vote against Article X of the RCSC Articles
of Incorporation. We are going forward with a much-needed class action lawsuit against RCSC over many causes of action,
including this one. We are contacting plaintiffs who, additionally, want RCSC to restore our membership meetings and
the membership quorum, comply with the planned communities act for open meetings and open records, and treat members equally
according to Article VIII.5. The members who are being victimized are singles paying a per lot assessment, homeowners
whose primary Arizona residence is within 75 miles of Sun City, residents who are not owners, owners with multiple properties,
people who paid the PIF, and members who buy guest cards. If you want to be a plaintiff to possibly get reimbursed for
illegal assessments, contact Anne Stewart at 602-318-0708 or 623-933-6192. Fundraising has ceased. We are funded.
It won't cost anything to be a plaintiff.
click here to download file: "More RCSC renovation in store"
click here to download file: "RCSC board split but still raise preservation fee"
click here to download file: "Divided RCSC board approves $500 hike in preservation fee"
4/29/15:
"Protest
proposed hike" by Anne Randall
Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
This opinion piece is against the RCSC's plans to increase the PIF from $3,000 to $3,500 at the 9 a.m. board meeting at Sundial
Auditorium on Thursday, 4/30/15. Please attend and protest.
PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, APRIL 29, 2015, OPINION,
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PAGE A4 AND A8
click here to download file: "Protest proposed hike"
4/29/15:
"PIF proposal represents
'unequal responsibility'" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry
and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
This opinion piece is against the RCSC's plans to increase the PIF from $3,000 to $3,500 at the 9 a.m. board meeting at Sundial
Auditorium on Thursday, 4/30/15. Please attend and protest.
PUBLISHED DAILY NEWS-SUN, APRIL 29, 2015, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PAGE A11
click here to download file: "PIF proposal represents 'unequal responsibilities'"
4/15/15: Newspaper Articles "The PIF to get puffed" by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent Front Page Story on April 15, 2015 Subject: RCSC to increase PIF from $3,000 to $3,500. They can raise it to anything
they can get away with unless the members come out to protest. PROTEST on Thursday, April 30, 2015, 9 a.m., at Sundial
Auditorium at Boswell Bl and 103rd Av. We want to challenge the PIF in court. It is an unequal responsibility
that is prohibited by RCSC Art. VIII.5. What more can you do about
it? PROTEST. Donate to the "Anne Stewart" legal fund. (Donations are not tax deductible or refundable.)
click here to download file: RCSC 4/30/15 Agenda-$3,500 PIF Vote
Click here to download file: "The PIFF to get puffed"
11/26/14:
"Application
was false" by Anne Randall
Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
The Sun City Formula Registry stopped a $200,000 boondoggle. Ever vigilant! Fundraising for the "Anne Stewart Legal Fund" is ongoing.
Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana
Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible or refundable. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, NOVEMBER 26, OPINION, LETTERS TO
THE EDITOR, PAGE 16
click here to download file: "Application was false"
click here to download file: "RCSC, dog owners working on issues"
6/27/14: Home UPDATE: Changed our "motto"
from "The Action of the Members" to "The Action of the Members, protecting Sun City's wallets". With
our upcoming class action lawsuit, we discovered SCFR is the only volunteer group in Sun City that is trying to control the
spending and assessing (especially illegal) of the RCSC; this change more clearly defines our mission. Coupling that
with the Bulldog watchdog, we want the Members of RCSC to also become Members of SCFR by contributing to the "Anne Stewart
Legal Fund" aka the "Bulldog War Chest" that pays for counsel to represent the Members of the RCSC corporation
when the RCSC corporation is in non-compliance with state statutes and the community documents. We will file our lawsuit
when we deposit $30,000 in a trust account with our counsel Jonathan Dessaules. See "About the Anne Stewart Legal Fund" for our progress in fundraising.
6/8/14:
Jonathan Dessaules, Esq., takes over for Nancy Mangone, Esq.
Subject: Nancy Mangone, Esq., leaves us to become Assistant
City Attorney for the City of Glendale. Jonathan Dessaules, Esq., picks up the banner as our counsel. He is the
one who proved The Anthem Community was held under the planned communities act in Rodgers v. ACC in the Appeals Court. Since
RCSC is claiming not to be held under the planned communities act like Anthem did, Mr. Dessaules is well-prepared to handle
our case. Fundraising is ongoing. PHOTO: Anne Randall Stewart and Jonathan Dessaules, Esq.
5/15/14:
5/12/14:
"No indebtedness,
no miracle" by Anne Randall
Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
Rebuts RCSC James Brasher's April 24 Daily News-Sun guest commentary entitled, "Miracles without debt," which is
no miracle since RCSC just takes the money it needs (and more) directly from the homeowners, buyers, and beneficiaries, at
$3,000 a pop. RCSC has increased assessments and is proceeding with more multi-million-dollar projects without a membership
vote. We need a judge to stop them. Fundraising for the "Anne Stewart Legal Fund" is ongoing. Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ
85351, with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible or refundable. PUBLISHED DAILY NEWS-SUN, MAY 12, 2014, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PAGE A16
click here to download file: "No indebtedness, no miracle" DN-S
5/7/14:
"Not
really a miracle" by Anne
Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
Rebuts RCSC James Brasher's April 23 Sun City Independent guest commentary entitled, "Miracles without debt," which
is no miracle since RCSC just takes the money it needs (and more) directly from the homeowners, buyers, and beneficiaries,
at $3,000 a pop. RCSC has increased assessments and is proceeding with more multi-million-dollar projects without a
membership vote. We need a judge to stop them. Fundraising for the "Anne Stewart Legal Fund" is ongoing. Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ
85351, with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible or refundable. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, APRIL 7, 2014, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PAGE A5
click here to download file: "Not really a miracle" Sun City Ind.
UPDATE circa May 2014-- Grand Avenue is again in the news. ADOT is proposing changes at
Bell/Grand Ave intersection. Option A is a freeway-style overpass with on and off ramps. We support this. Our
goal is to make Grand Ave a freeway where traffic from Wickenberg can continue on though the small towns to Phoenix, Sky Harbor
airport or Tucson and back again. The small towns want to keep traffic for the locals. If this project is approved,
Sun City needs to keep at it until there is an elevated freeway over Sun City with on and off ramps at 99th Av and 111th Av.
That would leave Grand Av beneath it to the locals with their golf carts, mobile wheelchairs and pedestrians. Read
our 2008 Grand Freeway Proposal. Except for the contact information, it pretty much says it all. What is true holds true forever.
3/03/14:
"Quorums in Sun City are important, very important" by
Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject: Rebuts RCSC James Brasher's
Feb. 20 Daily News-Sun opinion piece entitled, "Quorum? Is it important?" RCSC has removed membership
power and is planning more increases in assessments and more multi-million-dollar projects without a membership vote. We need
a class action lawsuit to force compliance with state statutes and the community documents. Fundraising for the "Anne
Stewart Legal Fund" is ongoing. Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund"
notation. (Donations are not tax deductible or refundable.) PUBLISHED DAILY NEWS-SUN, MARCH 3, 2014, OPINION, GUEST COMMENTARY, PG A14
click here to download file: "Quorums in Sun City are important, very important"
"SCHOA not likely affected
by ruling" Sun City Independent, December
18, 2013; by Rusty Bradshaw
Subject: SCHOA is claiming the PORA
lawsuit outcome does not apply to them. If you are being illegally fined by SCHOA, contact the attorney who beat PORA
on the issue. If PORA cannot fine, most likely neither can SCHOA.
click here to download file: "SCHOA not likely affected by ruling"
12/11/13:
"Not
following own rules" by Anne
Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
Rebuts RCSC James Brasher's Nov. 27 Sun City Independent guest commentary entitled, "Show me the money," which sounds
like something a robber would say at a teller window. RCSC is planning more increases in assessments and more multi-million-dollar
projects without a membership vote. We need a judge to stop them. Fundraising for the "Anne Stewart Legal Fund"
is ongoing. Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526
W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, DECEMBER 11, 2013, OPINION, LETTERS
TO THE EDITOR, PGS 4-5
click here to download file: "Not following own rules" by Anne Randall Stewart
12/6/13:
"As a matter of law, PORA does not have the power to enforce fines against homeowners for violating the
CC&R's." Holmes v. PORA Sup Ct Findings Conclusions SJ (CV 2012-018098) (8/29/13)
Anne Report:
If PORA does not have the power, then SCHOA most likely does not either. If you are a victim of illegal fine enforcement
by SCHOA, contact Plaintiff Holmes's attorney to ask him what you should do about it.
Attorney contact
information:
Matthew A Klopp (023313) mklopp@wonfujiicarter.com Ben J. Himmelstein (023267) WONG FUJII CARTER, P.C. Phoenix, Arizona 85012 (602) 287-3360
click here to download file: Holmes v. PORA Sup Ct Findings Conclusions SJ
12/02/13:
"Nothing prudent about RCSC financial policies" by
Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject: Rebuts RCSC James Brasher's
Nov. 21 Daily News-Sun opinion piece entitled, "RCSC stays on fiscally prudent path." RCSC is planning more
increases in assessments and more multi-million-dollar projects without a membership vote. Fundraising for the "Anne
Stewart Legal Fund" is ongoing. Donate to "Anne
Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax
deductible. PUBLISHED DAILY NEWS-SUN, DECEMBER 02, 2013, OPINION, GUEST COMMENTARY,
PG A10
click here to download file: "Nothing prudent about RCSC financial policies" by Anne Randall Stewart
11/13/13:
"Pursuing truth, justice" by
Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject: Rebuts Amber Henshaw's
and RCSC James Brasher's "facts" which are actually "misrepresentations of fact." It appears to
us that the RCSC is on a campaign to block fundraising for the "Anne Stewart Legal Fund." Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal
Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED SUN CITY
INDEPENDENT, NOVEMBER 13, 2013, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PG 4
click here to download file: "Pursuing truth, justice" by Anne Randall Stewart
10/25/13:
Still worried about the roof over the Sundial
indoor pool collapsing again due to improper maintenance. Added an article to the "Remember Sundial" feature
that is permanently on our home page, "Lest we forget!" Article: "Stainless steel in indoor swimming pool buildings":
10/16/13:
"What is axe to grind?" by
Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject: Opinion points out that RCSC General Manager Jan Ek's defenders are former RCSC board members who directly
caused our class-action lawsuit because they voted to illegally increase the quorum for membership meetings. Also, points
out that strident critic Amber Henshaw can't be found in the white pages, isn't listed on Maricopa County's property tax rolls,
and doesn't have an RCSC Facilities Agreement that we could find. Ergo, the question: "What's her axe to grind?"
Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation.
Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, OCTOBER 16,
2013, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PG A4
click here to download file: "What is axe to grind?" by Anne Randall Stewart
9/25/13:
"Projects should get vote" by
Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
Urging "Call to Action" to attend Sept. 26, 2013, RCSC board meeting to protest multi-million-dollar projects being
approved by the board without a Membership vote. Article X of the RCSC Articles of Incorporation require a Membership vote. Sept.
26 is supposed to be a quarterly Membership meeting, but the board did not call one. The RCSC illegally removed Membership
action. Attend and protest. We want a vote and we want our Membership meetings back. Attend 9/26/13, 9 a.m., Sundial
Auditorium at 103rd Av & Boswell Bl. Sign up to speak BEFORE the meeting.
Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation.
Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, SEPTEMBER 25,
2013, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PG A4
click here to download file: "Projects should get vote" by Anne Randall Stewart
9/13/13: CALL TO ACTION!
PROTEST!
RCSC
Board Meeting Sundial Auditorium 103rd Av & Boswell Thursday,
September 26, 2013 9 a.m. Protest the board's continued violation of Article X. THE MEMBERS MUST VOTE FOR PROJECTS OVER $750,000!!! Protest the board's removal of Quarterly Membership Meetings. THE MEMBERS MUST BE ABLE TO OVERRIDE BOARD ACTIONS!!! September 26th is supposed to be a Quarterly Membership Meeting. ATTEND AND TAKE
IT BACK!!!
click here to download file "Call to Action" for 9/26 RCSC Meeting
9/12/13: About the RCSC Lawsuit
Added Mangone/RCSC
September 2013 Letter
Subject: RCSC is planning to approve without a membership vote The Long Range Plan which includes
many projects that have "direct or contingent liability" of over $750,000 contrary to RCSC Articles of Incorporation Article X. The RCSC/SCFR Membership's
counsel, Nancy Mangone, sent an email with hard copy to follow to the RCSC Board's counsel, James Heinton, to advise his clients
that the RCSC Board has been notified that they have been in violation and will be again after the September 26, 2013, board
vote, and that the lawsuit will proceed.
click here to download file: Mangone/RCSC September 2013 Letter
9/3/13:
"Nothing improper in actions" by George T. McClain,
Sun City
Subject: Rebuttal to RCSC's many slanderous letters against Anne
Randall Stewart. Mr. McClain says Anne Stewart is doing a good job at holding the elected board accountable to the members
and lists many of the actions of the board which required the action of the members to reverse. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, SEPTEMBER 3, 2013, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PG A4
click here to download file: "Nothing improper in actions" by George T. McClain
8/28/13:
"Obey laws, own documents" by
Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry and Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
Rebuttal to RCSC's many slanderous letters against Anne Randall Stewart, namely board supporter Jacque Mills, whose letter
was an attempt to dissuade people from donating to the "Anne Stewart" Legal Fund which pays for our class-action
lawsuit against the RCSC for non-compliance with state statutes and the community documents.
Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation.
Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, AUGUST 28,
2013, OPINION, LETTERS TO THE EDITOR, PG A4
click here to download file: "Obey laws, own documents"
8/21/13:
"Stewart has valid points" by
Ken Gegg
Subject: Rebuttal to RCSC's
slanderous letters against Anne Randall Stewart. Mr. Gegg points out that the letters are attempts to dissuade people
from donating to our lawsuit. Donate to "Anne Stewart",
10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, AUGUST 21, 2013, OPINION, LETTERS, PG A4
click here to download file: "Stewart has valid points" by Ken Gegg
click here to download file: "Summer of Construction"
7/31/13:
"Working
for accountability" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry, Publisher
of annereport.com
Subject: Rebuttal to "Hold the course, RCSC" by Katie McCullough
which appeared in the July 16, 2013, issue of the Independent. McCullough disparaged Anne Stewart and The Sun City Formula
Registry for wanting to take the RCSC to court to compel them to obey state statutes and the community documents. She
is spouting what is becoming known as the "RCSC talking points" to dissuage members from donating to the "Anne
Stewart" legal fund. (Donate
to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations
are not tax deductible.) PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, JULY 31, 2013, OPINION,
LETTERS To the Editor, PG A15
click here to download file: "Working for accountability"
7/3/13:
"Needs membership vote" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson
for The Sun City Formula Registry, Publisher of annereport.com
Subject: Rebuttal
to "RCSC goes solar--What does that mean?" by the RCSC board. RCSC admits panels will cost $4.4 million in
66 months. Article X requires a membership vote at $750,000 threshold.
Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with "Legal Fund" notation.
Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, JULY 3, 2013, OPINION,
LETTERS, PG 4
click here to download file: "Needs membership vote"
6/5/13:
"Beware fundraiser prevention" by
Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry, Publisher of annereport.com
Subject:
Rebuttal to RCSC's slanderous letters against Anne Randall Stewart and thanking Judge James Treece for his May 29 letter of
support. The RCSC is trying to prevent fundraising for the lawsuit that will bring them to justice. Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351,
with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED
SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, JUNE 5, 2013, OPINION, LETTERS, PG 4
click here to download file: "Beware fundraiser prevention"
5/29/13:
"In support of Stewart" by
James Treece, U.S. Attorney for Colorado under 3 Presidents, Retired Judge, Former Sun City Taxpayers Association board officer,
Former member of the RCSC Legal Committee
Subject:
Rebuttal to RCSC's slanderous letters against Anne Randall Stewart. Judge Treece states he told the board they should
have brought the quorum issue before the legal committee and that they should not listen to Craig Brown its chair. (Brown
shut down the legal committee. The transcript is footnoted and a link to it and the video of the May 27, 2010, board
meeting are below.) The quorum issue is one of the causes of action in our contemplated class-action lawsuit against
RCSC for which we are seeking funding. We are honored that Judge Treece has donated and has come to our defense. Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351,
with "Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED
SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, MAY 29, 2013, OPINION, LETTERS, PG 4
click here to download file: 5/29/2013 Treece Letter and 5/27/10 Meeting transcript
click here to download file: 5/27/2010 Board Meeting Video
5/15/13:
"Fundraising has purpose" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson
for The Sun City Formula Registry Subject: Rebuttal to RCSC President Jim Brasher's
letter of May 8 where he called Anne Randall Stewart and The Sun City Formula Registry a scam. Of course, it is not,
and so required this letter of rebuttal. Donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351, with
"Legal Fund" notation. Donations are not tax deductible. PUBLISHED
SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, MAY 15, 2013, OPINION, LETTERS, PG 22
click here to download file: "Fundraising has purpose"
3/20/13: "More clubs will follow band" by Anne Randall Stewart,
Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry, Sun City Independent, March 20, 2013, Page A16 Letters Subject: The RCSC
is now charging members to rent the facilities which have already been paid for by their mandatory assessments. These
charges make using the venues for their clubs unaffordable. The clubs are leaving the RCSC. Our lawsuit (Anne
Randall Stewart, The Sun City Formula Registry, et al., vs. RCSC) will be challenging these charges along
with many other important causes of action. Donate to the "Anne Stewart" Legal Fund. Click here to donate. Click here to follow the lawsuit.
click here to download file: "More clubs will follow band" by Stewart
"Cost is
too high" by Len Shykind,
Sun City Independent, March 20, 2013, Page A16 Letters Subject: The RCSC
is now charging members to rent the facilities which have already been paid for by their mandatory assessments. These
charges make using the venues for their clubs unaffordable. The Sun City Pops Band had to leave because of these charges,
and we also will not have two craft fairs this year because of it. Our lawsuit (Anne Randall Stewart, The Sun City
Formula Registry, et al., vs. RCSC) will be challenging these charges along with many other important causes
of action. Donate to the "Anne Stewart" Legal Fund. Click here to donate. Click here to follow the lawsuit.
click here to download file: "Cost is too high" by Len Shykind
3/7/13: "Sun City Pops Band leaves Sun City fold -- Concert Band
chooses to stay for time being" -- Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent, March 6, 2013,
front page story Subject:
The RCSC charged the bands rental and rehearsal fees that priced the non-profit clubs out of Sun City. The Anne Report: More money-grubbing tactics by the RCSC board of directors and management which are ruining Sun City and making it
too expensive for members to participate. Rental and guest fees are unequal member responsibilities that conflict with
the articles of incorporation. Guests are guests by definition so should be free since the member is charged, not the
guest; and rental charges are unequal assessments since the members of the clubs have already paid their equal share toward
the creation and maintenance of the facilities. The facilities, equipment, and employees are already paid for a year
in advance whether or not anyone uses them. It is illegal for the board to write policies that conflict
with the articles of incorporation which states all members have equal responsibilities. The articles state the mission
of the board is to act for the benefit of the members. This rental/guest fee policy is not for the benefit of the members
as evidenced by its causing a club to leave Sun City, with possibly more to follow. The membership should
be aware now more than ever before how important it is to establish a permanent legal fund to protect membership interests
when boards act illegally. The RCSC has systematically worked to thwart "the action of the members" other
than lawsuit. The members pay for insurance that will represent the board in litigation, but the insurance doesn't cover
the members who bring action against RCSC wrongdoing. The
Sun City Formula Registry is the only group that has established a legal fund for that purpose. Please contribute. (Contributions
are not tax deductible.)
click here to download file: "Sun City Pops Band severs ties with Sun City" (DN-S 3/1/13)
click here to download file: "Sun City Pops Band leaves Sun City fold" (Ind 3/6/13)
2/27/13: We've added "About the RCSC Lawsuit" for materials and progress reports. Our attorney's letters have been ignored which leaves it up to the
Members to file a class-action lawsuit. As you know, the RCSC board and management feel confident in their silence since
lawsuits cost money. The RCSC has the Members' money to pay for their insurance policy that protects the board against
the Members' interests. It is up to the Members to finance their own representation. The Members are now represented
by counsel (Nancy Mangone, Esq.) and have a willing plaintiff (Anne Randall Stewart) to carry the class-action lawsuit forward.
We need continued financial support to complete the endeavor. No elected board should be permitted to disobey
state statutes and the community documents. Only civil litigation will compel compliance. We cannot call Sheriff
Joe to help us. The Members must step up and get it done once and for all. We're going door-to-door in our
fundraising effort and appreciate your courtesy when we meet you in person. Thanks for your support!
2/20/13:
Viewpoint Lake clears state regulatory
hurdle" by Jeff Dempsey, Daily News-Sun, February 20, 2013, front page and A5 Subject:
Jan Ek admits to "secretly" working with ADWR to get breaks in the water allocation for Viewpoint Lake if the RCSC
installs irrigation systems on some golf courses and teaches the members to conserve water. Sounds good on the surface,
but we want to see documentation. Secrecy is one of the claims in the lawsuit against the RCSC. After 30 years,
the Lake needs to be relined and the RCSC has the money in hand to get it done. This "secret" action by Jan
Ek is being used to let the RCSC off the hook to live up to their contractual obligations to fix the lake.
click here to download file: "Viewpoint Lake clears state regulatory hurdle"
1/26/13: Anne Reports The RCSC failed to answer our attorney Nancy Mangone's August 22, 2012,
letter! LAWSUIT IS NOW REQUIRED! Attorney Mangone sent a follow-up letter on January 24, 2013, which confirms
that RCSC's continuing non-compliance with Arizona revised statutes and its own community documents in intolerable and must
be brought before a court. Fundraising is now underway. Please donate. (donations are not tax deductible). WE NEED FUNDING TO PROCEED. Hard copies of letters and flyers are available at The
Send Me Store, Talisman and Del Webb. Please use them to spread the word. Or, print it out here:
click here to download file: Mangone/RCSC January 2013 Letter
click here to download file: Mangone/RCSC August 2012 Letter
1/16/13:
"Title 10 vs. Title 33--Attorney requests changes, resident gears for lawsuit" -- Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent, January 16,
2013, front page and Page 28 Subject: The RCSC ignored SCFR
attorney Nancy Mangone's August 22, 2012, letter that alleged the RCSC is not in compliance with state statutes and its own
community documents. The board illegally increased the quorum for membership meetings and then discontinued a director-member
exchange meeting. After receiving Mangone's letter the RCSC proceeded to eliminate quarterly membership meetings and
approve multi-million-dollar projects without a membership vote. These actions indicate they are not going to discuss
compliance. There are more than these causes of action. It is time to argue our numerous
complaints in court. As a result, Anne Randall Stewart is collecting the funds needed to go all the way to the appeals
court, if necessary. The membership should be aware now more than ever before how important
it is to establsih a permanent legal fund to protect membership interests when boards act illegally. The RCSC has systematically
worked to thwart "the action of the members" other than lawsuit. The members pay for insurance that will represent
the board in litigation, but the insurance doesn't cover the members who bring action against RCSC wrongdoing. The Sun City Formula Registry is the only group
that is establishing one for that purpose. Please contribute. (Contributions are not tax deductible.)
click here to download file:"Title 10 vs. Title 33 -- Attorney requests changes, resident gears for lawsuit"
1/13/13:
"RCSC
will review performers' plan" by
Jeff Dempsey, Daily News-Sun, January 12, 2013, front page and A5 Subject:
The RCSC is acting to cause the demise of our music groups. The board got wind of the music clubs using independent
contractor agreements to get around the $2 guest fees non-member band members must pay to rehearse and perform
at the RCSC. Director Bill Pearson is worried now the board will have to come up with something to thwart their idea.
There will be a Director/Member Exchange meeting at Lakeview Center at 9 a.m. on Monday, January 14 where you can go
to support the music clubs' idea. At a recent meeting,
Anne Randall Stewart encouraged the music groups to join our lawsuit against the RCSC; the RCSC does not listen to the members
and, in fact, did not even answer our attorney's letter requesting that they obey state statutes and the community documents.
Fundraising is now underway. Please donate. (Donations are not tax deductible.)
click here to download file: "RCSC board will review performers' plan"
1/10/13: Anne Reports On January 10, 2013, Anne Randall Stewart received a letter from the new RCSC President James Brasher
threatening and intimidating her. (And the beat goes on...) We suspect this to be another frame-up job. They framed her twice before with
false charges and said if there was a third time it would mean permanent expulsion. Anne Randall Stewart has obeyed every rule the board has thrown at the members even if they are
illegal rules. Permanent expulsion might mean she could not bring a lawsuit against the RCSC because she is not a member
in good standing. It would not behoove her to disobey the rules and forfeit her "member in good standing"
status. The letter accused her of circulating flyers on car windshields
at the RCSC parking lots. Friends of the Registry have been instructed to obey the rules (BP #11 and #14). The
Registry members circulate person-to-person, friend-to-friend. Even though we believe BP #11 AND #14 go against the
articles of incorporation because they thwart "the action of the Members", until we go to court to challenge them,
we must abide by the rules. The person(s) guilty of this "crime"
is either ignorant of the rules or is trying to get Anne Randall Stewart into "trouble". By the way, there
was no flyer enclosed with the RCSC letter even though the body of letter said there was.
click here to download file: 1/7/13 RCSC Letter Re Flyers
1/9/13:
"Music groups band against policy", by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun
City Independent, January 9, 2013; Page 2A and 6A Subject: The RCSC is acting to cause the demise of our music groups. At a recent
meeting, Anne Randall Stewart encouraged the music groups to join our lawsuit against the RCSC; the RCSC does not listen to
the members and, in fact, did not even answer our attorney's letter requesting that they obey state statutes and the community
documents. Fundraising is now underway. Please donate. (Donations are not tax deductible.)
click here to download file: "Music groups band against policy"
1/4/13:
Newspaper Articles
"Performers uncover options to club fees" Daily
News-Sun, January 3, 2013; by Jeff Dempsey
Subject: The guest fees were instituted by the board, not the members. The members never voted this extra tax on themselves.It
is never the guest who pays; it is the members. Only the members can buy the "Host" punch cards. The members have
already paid for the RCSC facilities through mandatory annual membership fees. The articles of incorporation require
equal assessments. Guest fees punish the members who wish to share their good fortune with their family and friends to entice
them to buy here, which is free marketing of the best kind. When the board's actions cause clubs to close, they are
going against The Formula for Successful Sun Cities: 1) create a sense of community, create a social network for the residents. The music clubs found that by having their musicians sign independent contractor
contracts they might be able to save their bands. However, they are still faced with a board that is doing all it can
to thwart their success. We urge the music clubs to join our lawsuit efforts so that the members can override board
actions. Only a lawsuit will compel the board to obey state statutes and the community documents. Click here to read "Performers uncover options to club fees": http://www.yourwestvalley.com/suncity/article_aca239a4-55c1-11e2-b702-0019bb2963f4.html#user-comment-area
12/24/12:
Newspaper Articles
"RCSC changes club guest fee policy" Daily News-Sun, December 21, 2012; by Jeff Dempsey
Subject: The guest fees were instituted by the board, not the members. The members never
voted this extra tax on themselves.It is never the guest who pays; it is the members. Only the members can buy the "Host"
punch cards. The members have already paid for the RCSC facilities through mandatory annual membership fees. The articles
of incorporation require equal assessments. Guest fees punish the members who wish to share their good fortune with their
family and friends to entice them to buy here, which is free marketing of the best kind. When the board's actions cause
clubs to close, they are going against The Formula for Successful Sun Cities: 1) create a sense of community, create a social
network for the residents. The RCSC does not need the guest fees to survive, but it does
need the clubs.
click here to download file: "RCSC changes club guest fee policy".
12/18/12: Anne Reports The RCSC is sneaking a $6-million project through without
a membership vote. There wasn't 10 days notice. Article X of the Articles of Incorporation mandates a membership
vote for any "indebtedness or liability, direct or contingent, over $750,000". It's a North Golf Course reconstruction
project led by a man who has never done a golf course before coming here. $2 million just for the irrigation system
alone. $6 million for a golf operation that has drainage ditches instead of golf course water features of Del Webb quality.
Remember the silk purse and sow's ear saying? Read The Daily News-Sun account
from yesterday: http://www.yourwestvalley.com/suncity/article_42251cb2-4866-11e2-b713-001a4bcf887a.html Here are all the motions for Thursday's board meeting including the $6 million
golf course project and BP17 that kills the orchestra, bands and dance clubs: http://sunaz.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Regular-Board-Meeting-Agenda-with-7-motions-12-20-12.pdf Attend and Protest: RCSC Board meeting Sundial Auditorium Thursday, December 20, 2012 9 a.m.
12/17/12: Protest the demise of the Sun City Orchestra and other bands as well as the dance clubs. Attend
the RCSC Board Meeting at Sundial Auditorium, Thursday, December 20, 9 a.m. One opinion expressed recently claimed the
musicians would pay the RCSC to perform because of their huge "egos". This kind of thinking should not be
the norm. It will ruin our sense of community. Click on this link to see how music can bring a community
together! Watch the faces of an audience of all ages. This could happen here. ---Anne Anne Randall
Stewart Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry ("The Action of the Members") Publisher of
http://www.annereport.com 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351-2218 (623) 933-6192 -- (602) 318-0708 cell anne@annereport.com
REMINDER: Donations to "Anne Stewart" with a "Legal Fund" notation are welcomed but are
not tax deductible. Thank you.
12/15/12: Open records! Good news! You don't have to bother
filling in a scary records request at the RCSC board offices stating your "reasons" for wanting to see their tax
returns! The IRS supplied them to Guidestar.org and you can see them for free without degrading yourself by begging. We've added 2010. Here it is:
12/12/12: Anne Reports The members showed
up to protest the demise of the bands and dance clubs but the board wouldn't listen. We can hold another protest on
Dec. 20, 9 a.m., Sundial Auditorium. The crux of the problem: "Guest must pay to use the facilities." That principle is ruining
Sun City. That principle eliminates the participation of the members with not enough money to pay extra to enjoy the
facilities with their family and friends in order to show them around to entice them to move here. There is no need
to charge members more. The facilities are already paid for a year in advance by the annual assessments. Charging
fees only allows the elites to use the facilities while they gouge the poor to foot the bill for them. The facilities are for the enjoyment of all. They
create a sense of community and were originally established as a marketing tool. The solution to the problem is to eliminate
all guest fees. Try it and see how enjoyment will flourish and the members will be happier. Click here to read the account of the meeting in the 12/11/12 Daily News-Sun Article, Front Page, "Sun
City residents bash compromise."
12/5/12 11/29/12:
"Proposed
fee conflicts with articles of incorporation" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City
Formula Registry Subject: The RCSC board is proposing to charge club guests $2 per visit.
We oppose any guest or rental fees because they extort unequal fees from the members which is illegal. The RCSC
articles of incorporation guarantee equal responsibilities among the members to maintain the facilities whether the members
choose to use them. The assessments are not usage fees. The board is not empowered to write rules that conflict with
the articles. MUST READ! PUBLISHED DAILY NEWS-SUN, NOVEMBER 29, 2012, OPINION, MY VIEW,
PG A10 (Also, PUBLISHED SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, DECEMBER 5, 2012, OPINION, LETTERS
TO THE EDITOR, PG 4 AND 6)
click here to download file: "Proposed fee conflicts with articles of incorporation" DN-S
10/23/10:
"RCSC: Fewer meetings = more people --- Residents concerned bylaw changes reduce member control", by Rusty Bradshaw, Sun City Independent, October 24, 2012; Front Page Story Subject: The RCSC is planning to remove quarterly memberhip meetings
and to approve multi-million-dollar projects without a membership vote. These actions are a direct result of our bringing
a complaint that raising the quorum for membership meetings is against the law. This board action turns the quorum into
a non-issue since there won't be any more meetings. Without membership meetings, there's nothing standing in their way
to spend the ill-gotten PIF gains on their pet projects with their pet contractors. It doesn't matter to them that the
PIF is an unequal tax and they can't tax people either on a property or on inheritance. These actions by the board should
make it clear to the members that our lawsuit is absolutely necessary. Please support us.
click here to download file
10/22/12:
"Sun
City watchdog group urges meeting attendance" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City
Formula Registry Subject: Attend to protest at the Board meeting on Thursday, October 25,
2012, 9 a.m. at Sundial Auditorium. Read the bad motions they are planning to pass unanimously unless the members show
up to stop them. The board is removing quarterly membership meetings and is approving milti-million-dollar projects
without a membership vote which goes against Article X. PUBLISHED DAILY NEWS-SUN,
OCTOBER 22, 2012, OPINION, MY VIEW, PG A6
click here to download file: "Sun City watchdog group urges meeting attendance" by Stewart
10/7/10:
Miscellaneous Links Added a link to another HOA having big-time problems with an out-of-control
spendthrift board of directors. Click the following link to
Fairfield Harbor: http://fhport.com/
10/3/12: Anne Reports On September
27, 2012, Noel Kasper delivered a letter to the RCSC at a board meeting requesting a petition to bring to a membership ballot
vote the issue of saving the Quarterly Membership meetings and the bi-monthly Director/Member Exchange meetings. Here
is the RCSC response by President Vance Coleman. In his letter dated Oct. 1, 2012, Coleman admits that the board voted
for "Motion #1" at the last board meeting despite our petition request. ("Motion #1" removed one
of two bi-monthly Director/Member Exchange meetings.) With our membership action to bring the issue to a membership
vote, the board did not act in the membership interest when it refused to table the motion until the outcome of the petition
drive.
Stay
tuned...
click here to download file: 10/1/12 RCSC Letter re Kasper-Stewart Petition Request to Save Membership meetings
9/27/12: Anne Reports
Noel Kasper delivered a letter to the RCSC requesting a petition
to bring to a membership ballot vote the issue of saving the Quarterly Membership meetings and the bi-monthly Director/Member
Exchange meetings.
click here to download file: Kasper/RCSC Request-Petition Letter
9/25/12:
"Watchdog
group urges attendance" by Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry Subject: Possibly the LAST quarterly membership meeting if the board has its way. Attend to protest
at the Board/Membership meeting on Thursday, Sept. 27, 2012, 9 a.m. at Sundial Auditorium. Read the bad motions they
are planning to pass unanimously unless the members show up to stop them. PUBLISHED
DAILY NEWS-SUN, SEPTEMBER 25, 2012, OPINION, MY VIEW, PG A10
click here to download file
PUBLISHED
SUN CITY INDEPENDENT, SEPTEMBER 25, 2012, OPINION, GUEST COMMENTARY, PG 5, "RCSC motions bad for members".
click here to download file
9/13/12: Anne Reports The RCSC ignored our
attorney letter. We must get financing to bring our case to court. You can help by circulating flyers and copies of attorney Nancy Mangone's
letter to the RCSC's statutory agent, James Hienton, Esq., regarding RCSC's non-compliance with Arizona revised statutes and
its own community documents. Hard copies are available at The Send Me Store, Talisman and Del Webb. Or,
print them out here:
click here to download file: URGENT Flyer (two on a page)
click here to download file: Mangone/RCSC Letter
8/22/12 Anne Reports The day has come to hold the RCSC accountable for its actions. Our attorney Nancy Mangone,
Esq., has sent a letter on our behalf to RCSC's statutory agent, James Hienton, Esq., regarding RCSC's non-compliance with
Arizona revised statutes and its own community documents. Hard copies are available at The Send Me Store, Talisman and Del
Webb. Or, print it out here:
click here to download file
3/3/12:
"Craig
Brown appointment is bad business judgment" by
Anne Randall Stewart, Spokesperson for The Sun City Formula Registry Subject: The RCSC President Vance Coleman's Feb. 27 My View warned the members that the board
is protected by the "business judgment rule". Remember the Sundial roof collapse? He also tried to let
Craig Brown off the hook for the demise of the legal committee. This piece reminds everyone that the upcoming lawsuit
is because of Craig Brown and his motion to illegally increase the quorum for membership meetings. Read more. To
support legal action, donate to "Anne Stewart", 10526 W Tropicana Cir, Sun City, AZ 85351. Donations are not
tax deductible. PUBLISHED DAILY NEWS-SUN, MARCH 3, 2012, OPINION, LETTERS, PG A10
click here to download file
|